These Marinated Cherry Tomatoes are crazy easy to make and so full of flavor you’ll want to put them on EVERYTHING!
Every year I plant cherry tomatoes in my garden.
They grow great in everything from portable containers to raised bed gardens and have been one of my go-to crops since I first tried my hand at gardening back in 2008.
Not-so-coincidentally, 2008 was also the year I started Peas and Crayons, a fun little foodie experiment I was eager to explore while working as a nutrition educator.
Fast forward to 2019 and my passion for this blog has only grown.
So in honor of my 10 year blogiversary, it seems fitting that we cherry tomato it up!
These marinated cherry tomatoes are INSANE.
Not only are they crazy easy to make, they’re so full of flavor you’re going to want to put them on EVERYTHING!
Here are some ideas to get you started:
serving suggestions for marinated tomatoes
- a tasty topping for avocado toast
- piled high on crusty bread to make the ultimate bruschetta
- as a salad mix-in that doubles as a dressing
- an epic side dish for all your summer grilling eats
- a topping for chicken, steak, or salmon
- on top of pizza or flatbread – heck yes!
- and so. much. more.
Whether you serve them up as an appetizer, a condiment, or as a scrumptious side dish, these marinated cherry tomatoes are sure to be a hit!
Marinated Cherry Tomatoes
Marinated Cherry Tomatoes
Ingredients
- ½ pound ripe cherry tomatoes quartered
- ¼ red onion sliced thin
- 1/2-1 clove garlic smashed and minced into a paste
- sea salt to taste
- ¼ cup quality extra virgin olive oil
- 1 TBSP red wine vinegar
- 1 lemon juiced
- freshly ground black pepper to taste
- optional fresh basil
Instructions
- Quarter your cherry tomatoes and slice onion into thin strips.
- Using the flat side of your knife, smash peeled garlic and mince into a paste. Season with a pinch of salt and add to a bowl with your veggies.
- Add olive oil, vinegar, lemon juice, freshly cracked black pepper, and fresh basil if you have some handy! Mix to coat the tomatoes and allow to sit at room temperature for 1-2 hours, stirring occasionally. Enjoy at room temperature and feel free to adjust salt and pepper to taste.
- These marinated tomatoes positively fantastic as a Summer salad topping that doubles as a dressing too! Pair with leafy greens, homemade croutons, and all your favorite mix-ins. It's also amazing atop toasted crostini as an appetizer and goes great on top of avocado toast too! The possibilities are endless. Enjoy!
Notes
Nutrition
If you get a chance to try these tasty marinated cherry tomatoes, let me know!
Leave some love in the comment form below or tag your photos with @peasandcrayons on Instagram so I can happy dance over your creation. I can’t wait to see what you put them on!
crazy for tomatoes?
My cherry tomato flecked Tomato Quinoa Salad is a reader favorite this time of year! You could even add these marinated tomatoes + onion to it!
Another great way to use up cherry tomatoes is in my feta-topped Cherry Tomato Salad and as a fiesta-worthy Cherry Tomato Pico de Gallo , perfect for taco night!
Lastly, this Tomato Cucumber Avocado Salad is paleo, keto, and vegan – making it a great choice for pretty much everyone
Questions & Reviews
How long will the tomatoes last in the refrigerator? Thanks.
Hi Tammy! These are fantastic the day of (so for sure try some the first day!) and then you can enjoy them for a few days after just like normal leftovers, up to 4 days. The longer they stay in the fridge the more the oil wants to solidify so just set them out to room temp for around 30 minutes to allow the oil to return to it’s liquid state and then you’re good to start snacking again! Leftover marinated tomatoes are amazing as a salad topper, bruschetta topping, and more!
Very good snack on toast 😋
So glad you enjoyed them Marc!
I haven’t made it yet but my Tom’s are ready to go, but what is their shelf life or are they meant to be used straight away?
Hi Jenny! So excited for you to try these rockin’ marinated tomatoes! I love them the day of — there’s something just so magical about them texture and flavor wise so I would enjoy them that day for sure. If you have a boatload of tomatoes for sure make some extra for the next few days though as you can enjoy them for a few days after just like normal leftovers! The longer they stay in the fridge the more the oil wants to solidify so just set them out to room temp for 30 minutes or so to allow the oil to return to liquid and then you’re good to go. The tomatoes will give off more of their juices over time so it will be more liquid-y and the tomatoes will be a bit softer but still tasty and a great little “prep ahead” topping for bruschetta and salads too!
This recipe looks fantastic. I will make it today. Do you know if it can be waterbathed to preserve?
So excited for you to try these marinated tomatoes, Julie! A reader who does a lot of canning mentioned that because of the oil they’re not a good candidate for canning so I would enjoy them fresh and then they can be stored in the fridge for a few days (same as typical leftovers) – simply bring them back to room temp before serving and you’re good to go! I hope you adore them as much as we do! xoxo
I made some of the marinated tomatoes at the end of last year and froze them they are delicious something to tied me up until the new crop ❤️
Can I can this in a hot water bath?
Hi Catherine! I always enjoy these fresh. For canning there needs to be a set acidity in place I believe? The websites for Ball mason jars might have some good info.
How much does recipe make?
How long will it last in frig?
Hi Jo Ann! I can’t recall the cup measurement but it’s a fairly small batch that I typically make in a standard size soup bowl. The intention is to enjoy it fresh, but if you make more with the intention of leftovers they can keep for a few. Since we’re working with a marinade, the oil will solidify the longer it sits in the fridge. Simply bring them back to room temp before serving, mix it all up, and dive in! Enjoy!
I just made this from home grown tomatoes. I will let you know what everyone saids. Thank you for the recipe
Hope y’all love them as much as I do!
Do you think that it is possible to can this?
Hi Lou! They’re meant to be enjoyed as a fresh tomato dish so I’m not sure how canning would change the flavors and textures. If you experiment with canning at all let me know how it is!
Experienced canner here. Because these are made using oil, unfortunately they are not safe to can and store.
Appreciate the info, Brooke!
Hi, i put together this recipe delicious, thank you. Should i store the marinated tomatoes in the fridge? Thank you, Bobbe
Will these freeze well? We have a bumper crop of cherry tomatoes and we can’t eat them fast enough
Hi Ellen! It’s meant to be enjoyed as a fresh dish but you could freeze a big batch of my roasted cherry tomato salsa recipe with great results!
Can this be canned and stored? How are for how long
Hi MZ! I’ve been so intimidated to try traditional canning, I need to start experimenting though – I’ve put it off too long! 😂 Have you tried the recipe fresh yet? It’s SO GOOD! I would start there and if you’re familiar with canning you could certainly see how it tastes canned compared to fresh. xoxo
It is an outstanding recipe and definitely a KEEPER!
Woooot! Thanks Amanda!
Quick Question – How long do the marinated Cherry Tomatoes last?
Hey Sarah! I really adore them fresh and highly suggest trying some that same day after marinating. They’ll keep for a few days stored in the fridge, around 3-4 days. Simply bring them back to room temp before serving to soften the oil (which likes to firm up the longer it sits in the fridge), mix it all up, and dive in! Enjoy!
As soon as my cherry tomatoes start to ripen, I start making this recipe. By the time cherry season has passed, my whole refrigerator is packed with canning jars of marinated cherry tomatoes–they keep well when refrigerated. I top all my salads with them and toss them with pasta and feta cheese. It’s a sad day when I use up the last jar and have to wait for the next season. You can always get cherry tomatoes in the supermarket, but part of what makes this recipe so delicious is sweet, ripe cherry tomatoes from the garden.
Help! I’m looking for a recipe that lets me use my hundreds of cherry tomatoes and dozens of black cherry tomatoes over the course of a year. Do you have recommendations for canning these? I also have lots of mint, some cilantro, and lots of several kinds of peppers, which I could use.
My neighbors love them, and I grow my vegetables and fruits to share with them and keep a few for myself.
Thanks,
Hi Lee! I don’t have any experience with traditional canning but the website Simply Canning appears to have tons of in depth tutorials on different types of canned tomatoes. For the peppers I love to make Quick Refrigerator Pickled Peppers and Quick Fridge Pickled Jalapeño Peppers and for longer term canning I’d check out Simply Canning and other canning-focused blogs for instructions and tips.
This was easy to make and delicious. I served the tomatoes over toasted slices of French bread along with pearl mozzarella, and my husband liked it very much. I loved it! What an easy way to increase one’s intake of fruits and vegetables. Thanks for a solid, got-to-make again recipe.
Thank you from one TX cook to another! ❤️ I’m so glad you enjoyed the recipe!
I love the flavors, must use fresh basil for best results.
How do you store the Marinatrd Tomatoes? And for how long are the good?
Hi Karen! I make them to enjoy that same day and if I have extra – store in an airtight container and bring to room temperature before diving back in. They should keep around the same as typical leftovers, 3-4 days.
I made this yesterday and my daughter and I loved it. I’ve made two more massive batches today to use up all the cherry tomatoes that are ripe from the garden. I’ve been very loose with the recipe, not measuring anything so it’s very forgiving. My 9 year old got up this morning and scoffed what we didn’t finish yesterday. Winner.
Soooo forgiving right?! I’ve entered that stage of just throwing it together off the top of my head and every variation has rocked my socks. So so glad you’ve have been loving the recipe — thanks Emma!
Once these are marinated and then refrigerated, how long will they last? Or is this recipe best for eating at the time that you make them?
Hi Heather! I really adore them fresh and highly suggest trying some that same day after marinating. They’ll keep for a few days stored in the fridge. Simply bring them back to room temp before serving to soften the oil (which likes to firm up the longer it sits in the fridge), mix it all up, and dive in!
I made this last summer and loved it! I just can’t remember if I used 8 oz for the tomatoes or is 1/2 lb different for tomatoes? Thanks
Hey Jeni! 1/2 lb is 8oz so you’re good! I’ve stopped measuring entirely at this point and just wing it most weeks, lol! So glad you’re loving the recipe!
Can I can this recipe?
Hi Beverly! Because it’s an oil based marinade (versus a salsa) I’m not sure how it would work canned. I’ve only had it fresh and adore it that way. Let me know if you get a chance to experiment!
I used yellow pear tomatoes. So delicious!! I’m serving them over avocado and toasted baguettes.
Excellent recipe! I prepared this exactly as instructed except I did add a bunch more cherry tomatoes. Oh my goodness, two hours later I brought in homegrown spinach from the garden and topped it off with all my homegrown tomatoes that had been marinating and had a yummy filling salad. Simple yet delicious…thank you for sharing…..
I would add a little bit of chopped jalapeño and cilantro instead of the basil.
That would be a fun spin on the flavors!
Looks delicious!!! If there’s any left over, do you refrigerate? The cherry tomatoes I buy says on the label, “Please don’t refrigerate, it’s too cold in there!” They’re called NatureSweet Cherubs. They sit on my table, I purchased quite a few this time, so I thought if I could make this, it could last for a few days at least.
Hi Carla! Fresh tomatoes last longer on the counter vs in the fridge so I’m guessing that’s why there’s a little note about it on the packaging. I do store leftover marinated tomatoes in the fridge (just like you would leftover fresh salsa) for just a few days. Usually by day 2 we’ve devoured the whole batch if we didn’t inhale it in one sitting, lol! Simply bring them back to room temperature before diving back in. xoxo
This is so good that I made it to use as a salad topping but ended up just snacking on it instead 🥴
Haha awesome! So glad you enjoyed the recipe, Jojo – thanks! It’s good so many ways! I’ve had it on leafy green salads, tossed into pasta salad, on crusty bread bruschetta-style, and it’s omg so amazing on top of a bagel with cream cheese.
Hi I’m going to make these tomato es. My question is how long to they keep in the fridge. Thank you.
Hi Rosa! Same as typical leftovers, I’ve kept mine up to 4 days but they usually get eaten pretty fast because around here! Bring back to room temp before serving for best results. xoxo
I think your beautiful display in the canning jar is what’s confusing to everyone.
It looks so amazing we all want to preserve it to last longer than it does.
Cindi you may be on to something with that! I’m a huge fan of glass jars for storage and use them for all my leftovers and for a lot of my marinades and sauces, lol! I’m so so honored the recipe has been such a huge hit with everyone. It’s a true favorite of mine!
Just perfect! So easy, so flavorful. I grow tomatoes, but am not in love with them. THIS recipe made me fall in love. Thank you!
Hey Jenn,
Dropping a note to let you know that I tried this recipe tonight and it did not disappoint! Flavor profile was perfect for the uses that you suggest. Making a salad for my wife tomorrow, and I’ll finish the rest with a softly toasted baguette.
Will post on Instagram shortly.
Thanks,
Mike
Thank you Mike! I’m so glad you enjoyed the tomatoes and thanks for sharing on Instagram too — so excited to see!
How long will this last in the jar?
Hi Deborah! They’re my favorite enjoyed fresh but if you’d like to save some for later that works too! Keep them in an airtight container in the fridge for a few days (about the same as normal leftovers) and when you want to serve them again, simply bring them back to room temperature to soften the oil/marinade.
Can this be canned? Looks super amazing!!!!
Thanks Sherri! I’m not sure about canning bc it’s intended to be a quick-marinated appetizer. I would say try it fresh first bc it’s so so good!
What is the shelf life of the marinated tomatoes?
Hi Jacqueline! I love mine best enjoyed on the day I make them but they will stay fresh for a few days in the fridge, just like normal leftovers would. Simply bring them back to room temperature and enjoy! Oil will solidify the longer it is refrigerated but will soften back at room temp. Hope you get a chance to try them! xoxo
I love these so much! I make them daily since I found the recipe!!! I wish we could can and keep them in the pantry!!!
What about using olives and capers ?
That sounds like a recipe for amazingness!!!! You could totally experiment with adding different amounts to get your ideal flavor combo of marinated veggies!
How do you store these?
Hi Julie! These will keep just like regular leftovers if you’d like to enjoy some later. Simply store in the fridge in an airtight container then allow them to sit at room temperature for a bit before diving back in (to soften the oil which can solidify over time when chilled) — enjoy!
How long will this last and can it be canned or would doing something cool the tomatoes
Hi Debbie! This dish is intended to be enjoyed fresh but will keep in the fridge for a few days – simply bring it back to room temp or leave it out a bit before serving to soften the oil based marinade (which can solidify when chilled overnight) — Enjoy!
How long do they last at room temp? Can you refrigerate?
Hi Deb! The current food safety standards for 2021 can give you a more exact idea, and I personally keep mine a room temperature for a few hours and then pop any leftovers in the fridge to enjoy later. They should keep for a few days in the fridge just like any other leftover and then simply brought to room temperature before serving to soften any oil that solidified when chilled. Hope this helps! xo
Can you preserve this recipe?
So far I’ve only had this recipe fresh or from the fridge within a few days. I’d imagine if canned they would not maintain their texture and would be more of a softened tomato spread vs a fresh tomato dish.
Can you freeze the marinated tomatoes??
Hi Patti! I personally enjoy them fresh so I have not tested out a freezer version.
Absolutely delicious! We have lots of ripe cherry tomatoes..Shared them with neighbours..Wondered how to use the plethora!
This recipe is the best! Will be my go to! Thank-you!
Looks super duper delicious!!!
I had to come back here to say THANK YOU! This is so delicious, I put it on a store bought prepared thin pizza crust with a bit of tomatoe sauce and light cheese….out of this world! Just, beyond words! Someone commented that it is summer in a jar, yes, indeed! I doubled the recipe and it won’t last two more days!
I substituted white balsamic vinegar, zest and juice from a pink lemon, and mushroom truffle rock salt, in addition to a few mini bell peppers, pineapple sage, celery leaf, African blue basil, purple ruffle basil and garlic chives from my garden and it turned out phenomenal! Topped w Buratta cheese and a sprinkle of truffle rock salt for a keto friendly salad that is very addicting. Thanks for sharing your awesome recipe 🙂
Absolutely the best taste ever!! I definitely added the basil, but not quite as much of the onion. This is summer on toast!
Hello, How long will this last in a covered container?
Hi Susan! About the same as standard leftovers – I think the USDA suggests up to 4 days (covered in the fridge) for foods like garlic/tomatoes and you can check the 2021 guidelines for more exact info. I usually make what I can consume in 1-3 days and they’re my absolute favorite on day 1 after marinating at room temp. Sometimes I’ll dig in after 30 minutes and other times I’ll wait a full hour or two to give them some extra oomph. They’re AMAZING!
Made this for Easter apps and it was a hit by all! Question in the event there are left overs how long would this stay good?
Yay!! So glad the tomatoes were a hit! I’m so obsessed with this recipe it’s ridiculous. Leftovers will keep a few days but need to be refrigerated. The marinade will solidify a little (because of the olive oil) but return back to normal once left out on the counter for a bit before diving back in. xoxo
Can you use dehydrated tomatoes to make this
Hi Norma! I would have to test it out as I haven’t come across dehydrated tomatoes yet. I believe it may be one of those recipes best with fresh tomatoes, though some sort of dehydrated tomato tapenade might be possible and tasty as a dip or spread for fresh bread. Let me know if you get a chance to experiment.
These marinated tomatoes are totally delicious!! I left out the garlic for IBS reasons and it was still superb. I also added a few pinches of salt to the olive oil mixture since I didn’t add salt during the garlic step. Will be serving with scallops, mashed potatoes, and micro greens tonight!
This recipe looks lovely and I will certainly try it this year.
How long can the marinated tomatoes be stored for?
Kind regards
Denise
Hi Denise! Excited for you to try the recipe. The tomatoes are good for a few days, about the same as leftovers, so I like to make what I’ll eat in a few days and then make more on repeat when the craving strikes!
Absolutely delicious! Goes great on bagels and cream cheese, crackers, avocado toasts, or on whatever you like.
Looked at picture, read the recipe, mixed everything together and then had a hard time giving it an hour to marinate. Absolutely delicious. I even put a small portion in the freezer to check on taste/texture after being frozen (??). I would love to have this available all year round – not just during tomato season. Thanks for sharing.
I’m so glad you enjoyed the recipe, Ruth! Keep me updated on your freezer experiment if you have a chance; I’m super curious! xoxo
Amazing! My cherry tomato plant was lackluster this year, but I finally got a decent sized harvest! This recipe is a great way to use up a bunch of ripe tomatoes, and it’s both delicious and simple. I’m looking forward to topping some spaghetti squash with the marinated tomatoes for dinner! Thank you!
Can I use Roma tomatoes instead of cherry?
Yes! I do this all the time and they work fantastic!
Sounds delicious – I would like to know how long I could store this in the fridge (IF it didn’t get eaten all at once!)
Hi Alice! So excited for you to try this recipe! (and yes totally hard not to scarf the whole thing lol!) The leftovers keep for a few days. They start to soften a bit more each day so I usually say 2-3 extra days to use them up. Simply bring back to room temperature before diving into the tomatoes and you’re good to go!
How do you get your tomatoes to not get smooshy. When I lightly mix it with a spoon everything doesn’t look at nice as yours and looks more like the making of pasta sauce.
Hi Camilla! Are you using cherry tomatoes or the longer grape tomatoes? Are they over-ripe by any chance? I’ve never had them resemble pasta sauce before so I’m wondering if being over-ripened can do that? Maybe they were extra juicy lol. Have you tried it yet? They should still be SUPER tasty scooped up with your favorite baguette or pita bread and one salads and such too!
How long will the marinated cherry tomatoes last in a jar?
Hi Christine! These will last a few days and should be stored in the fridge then brought back to room temperature before diving back in. I make a fresh batch every week and I’m so excited for you to try them!
Looks amazing ! How long will they last ? Can you give a deep water bath , as in making jam to last longer ?
Hi Sue! You’ve goooooot to try them! It’s more of a make it and enjoy for a few days sort of deal. They’ll keep same as typical leftovers for a few days in the fridge. Simply allow a little time to bring to room temp before serving and dive in! I like them fresh and usually eat most of them (if not all) within 30 minutes of making them, lol. As far as traditional canning I’m not sure how oil based marinates work with canning so I’d check with an expert there just in case. xoxo
I have a crazy amount of cherry tomatoes this year. How long will it last if I were to make big batches?
Hi Lisa! Since it’s a fresh prepared dish it’s the same as typical leftovers – just a few days.
So delicious, my family loved it. Like many others who have written here, there were no leftovers for the next day. Will definitely make this again- this recipe is a keeper.
Haha thank you Krista! Leftovers are hard to come by here too, they’re just begging to be devoured! xoxo
Hello, how long fo they last when done. Is this a preserve?
Hi Karen! They will last the same as normal leftovers – just a few days. I personally make a new batch every week when I have tomatoes handy – they’re my favorite the first day!
Would love to do these how long do they last in the jar
Hi Kim! These will last a few days and should be stored in the fridge then brought back to room temperature before diving back in. xo
So delicious and simple! Just wondering if you’ve ever used the juice from the marinade to marinate a second batch of tomatoes? We ate the first batch so quickly and there’s a lot of the liquid left. Have you used the remaining liquid to make anything else?
Awww yay – so glad you loved them! I’ve used it to make a second batch that same day for the exact reason lol!!! It also makes a rockin’ salad dressing.
I made a double batch and gave to 2 friends. They had to have the recipe. Was so good, ate it right out of the jar.
Fabulous!
Hello Jenn, I’m making these tomatoes again! They are just so crazy good! We’ve served them with burgers and hot dogs and topped avocado toast another time. Thank you for sharing such a wonderfu, easy recipe. Perfect for all those summer tomatoes.
Best to you, Jakalyn
Is this something I can jar and keep in the fridge for a while? Do you know how long the shelf life is?
Hi Camilla! Just a few days – I make a fresh batch every week in the Summertime. They’re SO good!
Will it be ok if I do not add red wine vinegar? Is there any substitute for red wine vinegar?
The vinegar brightens up the oil and flavors so I would try champagne vinegar, white wine vinegar, or a little balsamic vinegar to the mix! Another option is to add the juice of 1 lemon (or you can start with half and use the other half, to taste) and then add a little bit of one of the above vinegars.
How long can this recipe sit on the shelf. Or is there a different recipe to can them.
Hi Rhonda! These are not shelf stable so you would want to find a different canning recipe. I love them best fresh after they’ve sat out for a bit in the marinade and always suggest trying them that way first — they’re SO GOOD! xoxo
Making today how long can I keep in refrigerator
So excited for you to try them, Paula! You for sure want to try them on the first day before chilling (they’re my fav!). They will keep for a few days in the fridge. Simply bring them back to room temperature before serving (the oil thickens when chilled sometimes but melts back down at room temp) and enjoy on your favorite salad, crusty bread, avocado toast, etc… Enjoy!
For how long and where can these delicious tomatoes be stored. Put them on a hot dog; the tomatoes took the dog to a much higher level. Thanks for the recipe!
Yay! I’m so happy you’re enjoying them, Anita! They will keep for a few days in the fridge. Simply bring them back to room temperature before serving (the oil thickens when chilled sometimes but melts back down at room temp) and keep on face planting into them! xoxo
Can I can this agree making it?
Hi Karen! I am not familiar with how oil based marinades perform in canning. I typically make what I plan on consuming in a few days and love this recipe so much I make it nearly every week this time of year! xo
Have not tried this yet. Curious if you have to refrigerate at any point. And how long to they stay fresh?
Hi Ellen! This is one of my favorite recipes this time of year – we make a fresh batch every week! They will keep for a few days in the fridge and are best brought back to room temperature before serving. They get a bit softer the after the second day so I like to use any leftovers at that point to make bruschetta or as a topping for avocado toast!
Just made this today and it’s delicious! Is there a shelf-life to this or does it have to be consumed during the day? Thanks!
I’m so thrilled you loved them Chiqui! They will keep for a few days in the fridge and are best brought back to room temperature before serving.
I used grape tomatoes I threw in a little bit of chopped jalapeño and everything you said to do and they turned out beautifully
It’s the first time I marinated cherry tomatoes! And it’s from your recipe! They smell amazing so I am sure they will taste amazing as well. I changed it a little bit because instead of ordinary red cherry tomatoes I added yellow ones: https://gardenseedsmarket.com/tomato-cytrynek-groniasty-tiny-yellow-fruit-up-to-75-in-one-bunch.html . Have you ever used such tomatoes for marinating?
So glad you’re loving the marinated tomatoes! I’ve used the multi color cherry tomatoes before and added purple, orange, yellow, etc… It’s so tasty with every tomato I’ve come across! xoxo
I made one addition to your recipe, I added feta cheese. Gave it that Greek feel to it.
This was one of my favorite recipes!!! Made it this morning and had it as an app while we grilled. Served it on grilled baby naan. My husband just kept eating it. He love it!
❤️❤️❤️ This. Added 1 tsp. balsamic vinegar and sprinkle of red pepper flakes. I let it marinade while I made pasta. We let pasta marinate in tomatoes for about 15 minutes or so. Keeper.
Amazing! So good you could top ice cream (jk) but that good. Making them again today for company and bruschetta!
Thank you Nancy! I’m go glad the tomatoes were a hit! xo
Hi, how long do these keep and should they be refrigerated? Thanks!
Arg, sorry, I didn’t read the comments before posting my question! Never mind. 🙂
Hey Catherine! It’s about the same fridge-life as most leftovers and then just bring ’em back to room temp before diving back in! Hope you love them as much as I do! xo
I search online recipes all the time and have for years, but I have never left a review before. This is the best thing I’ve had in a very long time. I used it as a dressing over a simple salad of butter lettuce, I used it atop my red beans and rice…it was amazing! The only thing I did differently was to mash some oregano in with the garlic like my nanny used to do, otherwise I followed the recipe exactly and WOW!! Thank you!!
Can you can this and if so do you have the directions for pressure canning
Hi Kim! I have never traditionally canned these but I would check out my friend’s blog over at Wholefully.com <-- she has amazing canning recipes and instructions and might have some advice.
I have some cherry tomatoes that I need to use up and would love to try these. However I am along and would never eat this many at one time. Can they be stored in a tight container in the refrigerator?
Hi Penny! They’ll keep airtight in the fridge for a few days and there are a bunch of delicious ways to use them in the blog post such as a topping avocado toast, on a bagel with cream cheese, bruschetta, and as a salad topper. SO GOOD! I like to bring them back to room temp before diving in since the flavor is most intense that way.
This was so delicious. I’ve had it 2 different ways in the past 2 days. We mixed it with fresh mozzarella balls and basil for a picnic salad, which was great, but even better the next day spooned over toast with Goat Cheese spread. It’s so full of flavor! Will make again.
The only change I made (because I forgot to pick up a red onion…) was to use yellow onion instead, but it worked just fine. And I did add tons of basil (because I had it fresh in the garden). Thanks!
I made the marinated tomatoes and they are delicious but I am wondering how long they keep and how should they be stored?
So glad you enjoyed them Paris! They will keep for a few days in the fridge and are best brought back to room temperature before serving. They get a bit softer the after the second day so I like to use the leftovers to make bruschetta.
I added to a salad and used the juices as dressing with some extra lemon and it was fabulous. Next day I added to avocado toast with some feta and a fried egg!! Will be making again!
Yay!!! Both way sound absolutely amazing! I’ve had it on plain Jane avocado toast but your creation with feta and fried egg sounds EPIC – I’ve got to try it!
So, so yummy!! I didn’t have the red wine vinegar the first time so I substituted balsamic. The next time, I made it correctly but added a little balsamic because I liked it. I also added WAY more onions cause….marinated onions in my grilled cheese was happening!
How do you store them and how long do they keep for?
Hi Michelle! The tomatoes soften over time from the marinade so these are best enjoyed within two days. They’re my favorite on the first day but I’ll often pop any leftovers in the fridge to add to a salad (or pasta salad) the following day! Simply bring back to room temperature before serving. xoxo
These are so so good! I use half red wine vinegar and half balsalmic. Love it with the fresh basil!! Fantastic
Thank you Angela! I’m so stoked they were a hit!
I wonder if this could be canned for months out and enjoy the same good flavor?
Ooh! Let me know if you get a chance to experiment!
these were amazing! so fresh and delicious. I have to ask though…where ever did you find those cute little wooden spoons?
I’m so glad you enjoyed them! The little spoons were an Anthropologie find – love them so!
How are they kept? Do the Marinated Cherry Tomatoes have to be refrigerated?
Hi Barb! If you would like to save some for later, simply pop them in the fridge! Before serving, remove from fridge and allow to reach room temperature. Then enjoy! They don’t keep long term as the marinade will start to soften the tomatoes and onions quite a bit, so I typically make what we plan on consuming within a day or two. Hope that helps! xoxo
They were a hit on my bruscetta
Woot! Thank you Willow!
Delish! And a great quarantine meal! I had a tomato medley on hand that remained super fresh despite being in the fridge for 3+ weeks so I decided to make this to make sure they never went bad. I didn’t have red wine vinegar, only balsamic, so used that. And I didn’t have fresh basil but I had basil paste. I enjoyed mine on sourdough toast with some goat cheese and baby spinach. A great meal and something different! Mmmm!
Loved these – super easy! Used for bruschetta one day then on avocado toast the next morning!! Yum!!
These are wonderful. I made them while social distancing and to preserve some tomatoes from the grocery. I can’t wait to make with fresh tomatoes this summer. Should they be refrigerated or simply left at room temperature??
So glad you’re enjoying them, Mary! You’ll want to chill them for best results and then just let them come to room temperature before serving the next day. The oil will solidify a bit in the fridge then soften once room temp.
I made this and my whole family gushed about it!
I’m making these AGAIN today to take as a hostess gift tonight!
Ahhhh yay!!! Such a great idea – thank you Barbara!
Been doing something like this for years only thing different I put shellfish in with tomatoes as well.
Sounds like an awesome combo Peter!
Hi Jenn I am going to try this tonight. I am just wondering what the shelf life of this is
Hi Maura! So stoked you’re trying the recipe! They’re best enjoyed fresh that day.
Yay!!! So glad you loved them!
My whole family loves marinated tomatoes. It’s the perfect summer side dish. I also love eating them as a quick snack! Thank you for sharing your refreshing recipe.
OMG yes – best snack ever! I’ll be eating these all Summer long!
These r delicious OMG can u put them it the fridge
Thanks Evelyn! Ours haven’t made it to the fridge yet lol we keep devouring them all! Haha! From my experience the oil will solidify a little in the fridge so you should be able to pop them in there and just let them warm back up to room temperature before diving back in! xoxo
How long will they keep?
Hey Susan! I haven’t had a chance to check the 2020 food safety standards yet but the last time I read up on them they said about 4 days for prepared foods. I made some last night for an appetizer (sooooo goooood!) and have the leftovers chilling in the fridge for later today. The oil will solidify a bit in the fridge so simply leave them out to reach room temperature before serving and you’re good to go!